To mine or not to mine?

Our guide at the National Coal Mining Museum

Last week’s tragic events in the Swansea Valley serve as a stark reminder of the dangers of looking underground for our fuel sources. It came on a day when we joined the Archaeology and Anthropology section at the British Science Festival for a field trip to the National Coal Mining Museum in Bradford. We spoke with men who have worked in mines for most of their lives, and seen more than their fair share of tragedy along the way.

It’s easy to think of mining disasters as things of the past. While, thankfully, they are rare events in Britain, in other parts of the world they are far too common. Factor in the environmental effects of burning coal as fuel, and perhaps nuclear doesn’t seem so bad.

The day before our Festival trip to the Coal Mining Museum, physicist and TV presenter Jim Al-Khalili spoke to the Festival about his views on nuclear power, which are unashamedly positive.

‘There are tragedies, and I don’t want to belittle those’ he told his audience. ‘But the fact remains that nuclear power has a much lower death rate than coal’. Some estimates put the number of deaths per terawatt for nuclear at 0.04, with coal at 160.

Joining Jim Alhalili in the discussion was Professor Robert Cywinski, otherwise known as ‘Thorium Bob’. He argues for the use of thorium, rather than uranium, in nuclear power, since it doesn’t produce the nasty by-product, plutonium.

With the memory of the Fukishima disaster still fresh, and the 25th anniversary of Chernobyl this year, the resuts of a recent study commissioned by the British Science Association are surprising. They suggest that 37% of the UK population are in favour of nuclear power as a source of UK energy, with a surprisingly low 11% believing we should avoid nuclear altogether.

Meanwhile, we continue to be heavily reliant on coal, and as long as that continues, we will continue to send workers into mines. Like it or not, it is an important part of our industrial heritage, as a visit to the National Coal Mining Museum so clearly shows.

Is it now time to wean ourselves from coal? If so, surely nuclear has to be at least part of the alternative?

One thought on “To mine or not to mine?

  1. The issue will be debated however in such a turbulent economic climate i found that the construction and mining sectors are the key to solving the unemployment problem. We all know the age of the earth, and the age of technology is roughly refined in the past the 10years. A developed people is a happy people.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s